Al-Awda@yahoogroups.com |
April 2, 2001
|
|
Edward Said Repudiates Arab Intellectuals' Call to Ban Beirut Revisionism ConferenceDate: Tue, 3 Apr 2001 14:28:23 -0700 (PDT) From: Ibrahim Alloush Reply-To: Al-Awda@yahoogroups.com |
From: Edward W Said To: samaa Abu-Sharar Subject: Re: A message from Amman Date: Mon, 2 Apr 2001 07:15:17 -0400 (EDT) Dear Samaa, I don't have and never saw the memo since I was called by phone, told that there was no time to send a copy for me to see, and was asked to approve the text for signature. I did, on condition that there would be no appeal to any government concerning the banning of the conference. I don't believe a), in addressing governments and b), asking governments to ban anything, least of all conferences, books, etc. Having been the victim of such governmental decisions I couldn't put myself in such a position. I was very clear about this. The next thing I knew is that the statement appeared with a request to Hariri's government to ban the conference. All I had agreed to sign was a statement denouncing the holding of such a conference in Beirut. To repeat, I did not ask the government to ban it, nor would I ever. This request was added against my wishes, and without my knowledge. I am deeply opposed to holocaust-deniers but I am equally opposed to banning by government edict everyone's right to free speech. This was a terrible breach of confidence and a small group of franco-arab "intellectuals" simply betrayed my trust. To this day they haven't had the decency to send me a copy of what I supposedly signed. You may use any and all of the information I've sent you here. Best, Edward Said |